Abandoned Cart Subject Lines: A Simple Guide on Recovering More Carts

Editorial Team
March 11, 2022
Abandoned Cart Subject Lines: A Simple Guide on Recovering More Carts

As an eCommerce store owner, we know cart abandonment emails help recover revenues.

However, the problem is to get noticed amidst 300 billion marketing emails sent out each day.

To get your abandoned cart emails opened, you need compelling and eye-catching subject lines.

In this post, we will be covering the best examples of abandoned cart subject lines that have brought conversions.

Furthermore, we will look at how to set up abandoned cart automation with a definitive strategy to enhance your revenue.

Let’s get started.

A Common Mistake in Most Cart Abandonment Campaigns

On average, around 8 out of 10 online shoppers abandon their carts.

Most eCommerce stores have moved upfront to tackle cart abandonment scenarios by setting up automated sequences in their store.

They use decent abandoned cart subject lines, preheaders, and the content in their emails.

However, the result is not too noticeable.

But why? Because they often stop at just one email!

Sending multiple (at least three) abandoned cart emails brings in 69% more orders compared to one email.

Apart from sending out a well-spaced sequence of emails, craft subject lines that stand out and don't get lost in the clutter.

Performance of Different Abandoned Cart Subject Lines Used By Businesses

47% of email recipients open their emails after reading the subject lines.

Therefore, you must pay attention to subject lines when crafting your abandoned cart email campaigns.

As per Popupsmart, these are the stats of different abandoned cart subject lines:

  • Subject lines with “left something behind” get an open rate of 47.67% and a click rate of 11.21%
  • Writing emojis in the subject line get an open rate of 39.09% and a click rate of 8.58% 
  • Including the term "discount" in your abandoned cart email subject lines get an open rate of 38.31% and a click rate of 10.75%

Emails with captivating abandoned cart subject lines get more open and convert more often than usual.

Now that we have understood the importance of abandoned cart email subject lines let’s look at some tips to write them.

Tips on Writing Effective Abandoned Cart Subject Lines

Before you start drafting your abandoned cart email subject line, here are the four tips you must follow.

#1: Limit the characters on your subject line

The length of your abandoned cart subject lines is one factor that affects your email's open rate.

It’s important to convey your offer to shoppers with the right character count.

Keep your subject lines short and sweet!

Here’s a good example to start with:

Limit the characters on cart abandonment subject line

Since more than 50% of people read their emails on a mobile device, limiting the characters on your abandoned cart subject lines is important.

Experts recommend using 6 to 10 words (around 40 to 45 characters) on your abandoned cart subject lines for explosive open rates.

#2: Personalize your emails

Personalizing your emails enhances engagement.

22% of shoppers are more likely to open their emails with a personalized subject line than usual.

Some good CRMs like Autonami and a few others give options to personalize your subject lines as well as preheader text.

You can directly include merge tags such as the shopper’s first name, the item they added to their cart, etc., in your abandoned cart subject lines.

For instance, look at the following personalized subject line:

Personalized abandoned cart subject lines

Using personalization tactics in your emails will surely get your shopper’s attention.

#3: Leverage the preview text

Marketers leverage their email preview text to add continuity to their attention-grabbing subject lines.

Preview text is not mandatory like the subject line; however, writing your own preheaders gives you more control in helping your reader notice.

Look at this impressive example:

Leverage your preview text and abandoned cart email subject lines

Notice how the subject lines and preheader text are working together, exciting the reader to open this email.

#4: A/B testing

Eventually, no marketers can come up with an ideal abandoned cart email subject line.

They consistently use the A/B testing feature within their CRM to test multiple variants of the subject lines, preheader text, and body content.

Use different words or language in your subject lines and see which variation turns out the best among your recipients.

Then, implement these learnings to continuously refine and improve the performance of your cart abandonment emails.

5 Cart Recovery Subject Lines Used By The Best in Business

Over the years, we have analyzed a lot of cart recovery emails that businesses send to their shop abandoners.

Here are some of the major tried and tested types of abandoned cart email subject lines that you can use in your cart abandonment campaigns:

#1: The forgot something subject lines

Marketers quite commonly use the “forgot something” abandoned cart email subject lines because it fetches them great results.

It simply implies that the shopper has forgotten to checkout or accidentally left the website.

Take a look at the following email from Chubbies:

Cart abandonment "Forgot something" email subject lines - Example from Chubbies

Subject Line: Forget something?

Chubbies is known for injecting humor into their marketing copies.

Although their subject line doesn’t mention anything about the cart or product items, it engages customers with friendly language to attract users’ attention.

Here are some interesting subject lines that online stores send to shop abandoners:

  • You left something behind
  • Ooops, you forgot something
  • Did you forget something
  • Looks like you forget to checkout, complete your purchase
  • Your cart is ready

Such abandoned cart subject lines serve as a reminder for the user to complete their purchase.

#2: Incentive-included subject lines

48% of online shoppers abandon their cart because of associated high extra costs that include shipping, taxes, handling fees, etc.

To lure them into completing their purchase, marketers often use incentives in their cart recovery emails.

The offer could be anything like dropping the price on a particular item, giving free shipping, offering a percentage discount, and more.

Here’s an amazing example from Alex Mill:

Cart abandonment "Incentive-included" email subject lines - Example from Alex Mill

Subject Line: Get Them for 15% Off!

Notice how straightforward this email is.

The brand offers an exclusive discount of 15% to shoppers as an incentive to customers to complete their purchases.

Here are a few incentive-based subject lines that many companies use:

  • Empty your cart with 10% off
  • Hey, forget something? Here’s 15% off
  • Free shipping on your order
  • Price drop on your order! Complete your purchase now
  • Cold feet? Here’s something extra with your order

These incentivized subject lines help attract shoppers to make the purchase.

#3: Urgency-driven subject lines

You can capture your shopper’s attention by creating a sense of urgency in your abandoned cart subject lines.

Urgency-driven campaigns let people act fast on a certain deal or the product item at the risk of losing out.

Take a look at this beautifully-crafted recovery email:

Abandoned Cart subject lines on "Urgency-driven" - Example from Parachute

Subject Line: Our Sale’s Ending, Your Cart’s Calling

Parachute, a brand known for selling household products, creates a sense of urgency with the limited sales strategy. 

They inform their shoppers that they have limited time to purchase until their exclusive sale ends.

Here are some common urgency-driven email subject lines used by different marketers:

  • Your shopping cart is about to expire
  • Get your {item name} before it sells out
  • Hurry, the items in your cart are selling fast
  • Your cart is about to expire, still interested?
  • Your item is almost sold out

Using urgency-driven subject lines in your abandoned cart emails lets your users know about the limited time they have to make a purchase.

#4: FOMO-inducing subject lines

FOMO (or fear of missing out) is similar to urgency-driven subject lines but it rather focuses on the popularity of your product among other shoppers.

Such abandoned cart subject lines bring FOMO in their aid to draw shoppers back to their website and complete the purchase.

Look at this email from Vinomofo:

Abandoned Cart subject lines on "FOMO" - Example from Vinomofo

Subject line: We’re meant to be together

As you can notice, it complements the reader of their great taste. 

It also reminds them that there’s a lot of competition for the product among other shoppers, and for that reason, they have to act fast in order to avoid missing out.

Here are some FOMO subject lines used by many brands:

  • Look at what other customers love about {product name}
  • Still deciding? Let’s hear from other shoppers
  • Other shoppers are looking for the items in your cart
  • Shoppers are waiting - we might be unable to hold on to your cart
  • Let’s hear from {random shopper’s name} about {product name}

Using FOMO-induced subject lines in your cart recovery email followed up with some social proof from the shoppers will surely help seal the deal.

#5: Suggestive subject lines

These subject lines work on the assumption principle, which focuses upon that your customer is ready to make a purchase - all they need is a little nudge.

Here’s an example of suggestive subject lines along with the email:

Cart abandonment "Suggestive" email subject lines - Example from Kate Spade

Subject Line: Let’s check this off your list

It’s quite a straightforward abandoned cart email.

Instead of giving reasons or asking anything, it simply suggests the user complete their purchase.

The email assures the shoppers that customer care is nearby and will help if they encounter any issue during checkout.

Some common suggestive abandoned cart subject lines include:

  • Ready to buy?
  • You’re nearly there
  • Your new {product name} is just two clicks away
  • Is your wi-fi okay? You’re so close
  • Checkout will only take a few minutes

Now that we have looked at some classy examples, let’s implement them in our recovery email.

How to Send Abandoned Cart Emails from WordPress?

We need to set up automated sequences to send out cart abandonment emails.

Therefore, we will be creating an abandoned cart automation with 3 emails with specific delays like this:

Full Cart Abandoned Recovery Sequence

Setting up multiple emails in our sequence with impressive abandoned cart subject lines will help boost your conversion rate.

We will use Autonami to create this automation.

Autonami is the best marketing automation engine and broadcast platform for WordPress.

It has a variety of events and actions to fulfill all your use cases without writing a single piece of code.

Follow the step-by-step instruction below to create your cart abandonment automation in Autonami.

Step #1: Install Autonami 

First, you need to get a copy of Autonami.

Autonami is available for free. However, if you have some advanced requirements, get the premium version here.

Go to your WooFunnels account and download the zip files of Autonami that you get with your purchase:

1. Autonami Lite (base plugin)

2. Autonami Pro

3. Autonami Connectors

Download the zip files for Autonami

Install and activate all the files in the same order.

Next, copy the activation code from your account and paste it into the Autonami settings.

Activate Autonami

Clicking on Activate will lock your license key and you’ll then be able to use Autonami.

Step #2: Install an SMTP plugin

Setting up your WordPress site with an SMTP plugin ensures that none of your emails land in spam.

Out of all the SMTP service providers, we recommend the following plugins:

  • WP Offload SES Lite for Amazon SES
  • WP Mail SMTP for SendGrid, Mailgun, and Sendinblue
  • Postmark for WordPress to set up Postmark SMTP

Here, we will use the WP Mail SMTP plugin:

Here, we will use the WP Mail SMTP plugin on our WordPress website

Configure the settings for WP Mail SMTP by going through the setup wizard:

Configure the settings for WP Mail SMTP by going through the setup wizard

Proceed through the setup and configure the SMTP plugin.

Here is a quick guide to set up the SMTP plugin on your WordPress website.

Step #3: Add a new automation

Go to Automations under the Campaigns.

Then, click on Add New.

Add new automation

You'll see a list of automated recipes pre-designed for you.

Select 'Start from Scratch' and enter the name of your automation.

We will name it ‘Abandoned Cart Recovery Sequence’.

Name the automation ‘Abandoned Cart Recovery Sequence’

Clicking on Create will add your automation.

Step #4: Choose the event as 'Abandoned Cart'

Click on Select Trigger.

Select Trigger

Choose the Cart Abandoned event under WooCommerce.

Choose the Cart Abandoned event under WooCommerce

Click on Done to select this event trigger for your automation.

Step #5: Add a delay

Specify the next step of your sequence when the event triggers:

  • Action - Directly executes an action when the event gets triggered
  • Condition - Executes an action only if the condition fulfills when the event gets triggered
  • Goal - Specify the end objective of your automation
  • Delay - Add a delay to your automated sequence
  • Exit - Exit the automation

Here, we will be selecting the Delay.

Select delay

Configure the delay of 1 hour.

Click on Save when done.

Step #6: Add the 'Send Email' action

Click on the (+) icon and select the action.

Click on the (+) icon and select the action

Now, hit the Send Email action under Messaging.

Hit the Send Email action under Messaging

Click on Done.

Step #7: Design your abandoned cart email

You can create the content of your email with rich text, HTML, or using Autonami’s drag and drop editor.

Here, we will select Drag & Drop to create our first cart abandonment email.

Write your personalized abandoned cart subject lines, preview text and click on Launch Editor to design your email.

Write your personalized abandoned cart subject lines, preheaders and click on Launch Editor to design your email

Drag and drop the content blocks such as images, columns, text, headings, call to action (CTA) buttons, etc. to create your email content.

Let’s drag the image block to our screen.

Drag and drop the image block to create cart recovery email

Now, upload the image logo of your website.

Upload the image logo of your website while designing your cart abandonment email and subject line

Now, we will drag the text block like this:

Drag and customize the text block

Click on the text and customize it the way you want.

Now similarly create the rest of the email content.

To add the cart recovery link to CTA, go to Merge Tags.

To add the cart recovery link to CTA, click on Merge Tags

Click on Select next to the cart recovery link.

Click on Select next to the cart recovery link

Now, copy the cart recovery link code:

Now, copy the cart recovery link code

Then paste it to your CTA destination URL:

Then paste it to your CTA destination

Once done, click on Save to lock all the changes.

Press the 'X' button to go back to your automation workflow.

Step #7: Add more emails to your cart recovery sequence

Now repeat the above step and craft two more emails.

For the third email, we will create the incentive-based abandoned cart email subject line.

Let's include a personalized 10% discount coupon in the cart recovery email sequence for completing the purchase.

Select the merge tag ‘Create New Coupon’.

Click on Select merge tag next to ‘Create a coupon code’.

Go through the following details to create your personalized time-based coupon: 

  • Select the base coupon
  • Enter a personalized coupon name
  • Choose expiry in minutes, hours, or days
  • Set the expiration duration
Create your personalized time-based coupon

Once you’re done, copy this coupon code and paste it into your email.

This is how you can add a personalized coupon code to the abandoned cart email.

Add a delay of 24 hours to the second and 72 hours to the final email.

Ensure to craft a perfect abandoned cart subject line in your emails and check everything before you make the automation live.

Step #8: Go live with your automation live

Now, make the automation live by turning the toggle to Active.

Make your abandoned cart recovery sequence line

Well done, you have successfully created and activated your abandoned cart workflow.

Well, wasn’t it easy?

Ready to Set Up Cart Abandonment Sequences to Recover your Store's Revenue?

We looked at abandoned cart email and subject line examples and the various techniques that pro marketers are using to get a bang for their buck!

We also demonstrated how to send a well-timed abandoned cart email sequence.

But to do that from WordPress without letting any of your emails land in spam requires you to use the right tool!

This is where Autonami comes in.

It's a full-fledged tool that makes it easy to set up powerful abandoned cart sequences and various automated use cases that help dominate your business.

It’s a must-have tool if you’re running an eCommerce business.

So, what are you waiting for?

Get Autonami now and get off to a flying start >>

Author: Editorial Team
The Editorial Team at WooFunnels is a passionate group of writers and copy editors. We create well-researched posts on topics such as WordPress automation, sales funnels, online course creation, and more. We aim to deliver content that is interesting and actionable.
Ready to create revenue-generating funnels in Wordpress?
Click Here

Increase your sales, starting today.

Get WooFunnels Now
chevron-down
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]